Rule Number One:
Drama is better than Accuracy.
The GM should know what challenge he wants the player to face, look at their skill, and set the difficulty accordingly. For a simple task, go for a step or two below the best in the party; for something more serious, go the other way.
The following are examples from the book on what the different difficulty levels on
The Ladder entail. Some of the examples are a bit contradictory in places, and the table should be further refined, but it's a good guideline. (FUG 14-15)
- POOR (Neglible Difficulty) - Generally don't require a roll. As long as someone can physically do it, and understand what's being asked, it should be automatic.
- MEDIOCRE (Simple Tasks) - Most tasks an ordinary person meets routinely. Can be overcome without drama or struggle, assuming basic competence.
- AVERAGE (Mundane Tasks) - Would challenge the average person, but routine for experts and professionals. Someone with basic skills could do it in a pinch, but not with regularity.
- FAIR (Difficult Tasks) - Out of the realm of someone with only basic training. Noteworthy, and rarely approached with out preparation.
- GOOD (Daunting Tasks) - Skilled pros will balk, and a person may go their whole life without such a challenge. Requires a lot of training, talent, or both.
- GREAT (Staggering Tasks) - Only the best of the best need apply. Only a handful in the world could do this with any sort of consistency.
- SUPERB (Nearly Impossible Tasks) - Expanding the very nature of the task at hand. Revolutionary.
| Activity | Poor | Mediocre | Average | Fair | Good | Great | Superb |
| Computers | Turning it on | "Hello World" | Installing Linux | | | Developing an entirely new programming language | Developing the new Killer Ap. |
| Climbing | A ladder | A knotted rope | A cracked stone wall with handholds | A cliff face with equipement | The side of a building | A cliff face, bare-handed; Everest | A cliff face, bare-handed, in the rain |
| Driving | Start the car | Drive the car | Drive the car in the rain; parallel parking with <1' clearance | Drive the car in a blizzard; flying a small plane | Drive the car in a blizzard at high speed; flying a fighter jet | Race in the Indy 500; dogfighting | Stunt drive in an action movie. |
| Cooking | Microwave popcorn | A recipe | From scratch | | For a good restaurant | For one of the world's finest restaurants | Iron Chef |
| Juggling | Catching a ball | Juggling three balls | Juggling four balls | Juggling knives | | | |
| Medical | | Bandage a cut; treating a sunburn | Applying a tourniquet; CPR; splinting a broken arm | Simple surgery; , stitch a deep cut | Surgically repair a serious stab wound | Open heart surgery; repair a punctured lung | Surgically re-attach a severed limb; multiple organ transplants |
| Music | | Not scaring the pets | Marching band | | | Soloing for the New York Philharmonic | The next Beethoven's Ninth |
| Research | Reading the headlines | Searching with Google | Researching something obscure in the library | | | | Researching a new branch of science |
| Survival | Eating and drinking healthily | Starting a campfire | Build a shelter from the rain | Find potable water in the forest; digging a well; skinning an animal | Find potable water in the desert | Live in the desert for a week with no supplies | Live among the wolves as one of the pack |
| Swimming | Getting into the pool | Jumping off a low diving board | Rescuing someone in calm water | | | Swimming the Channel | |
| Other | Getting a joke on Leno | Writing a business letter; loading a gun; getting on a horse | Sewing a dress; | Building a house; rebulding a car engine | Designing an office building | Jackie Chan | |
| To put it into D20 terms, I'd be inclined to rank things as the following [D Cs]?: |
| Poor (5) - Mediocre (10) - Average (15) - Fair (20) - Good (25) - Great (30) - Superb (35) - Epic (40) - Legendary (45) |
FATE Mechanics